Monday, 17 August 2009

Subtracting from Talmud

An interesting Tefillah exists in the Talmud and in the Tur but was deleted from our daily cycle by the Bet Yosef and the Shulchan Aruch

The Tefillah is recited PRIOR to entering the Privy and maybe found AFAIK verbatim in TUR Orach Hayyim 3

The SA OH 3:1 mentions it and states "now we are no longer accustomed to say it"

The quoted sources in Be'er Haggolah
1 to say: Talmud Brachot 60
2 to omit: Bet Yosef

[Note: I have not recently seen this BY inside]

Questions:
1 How can the BY omit a Talmudically mandated prayer?
2 Why don't we restore it?*


Note:
A) The Shaarei Teshuvei quotes Arizal to restore it.
B) Artscroll and others restored the Talmudic "birkat Ba'al habayyit" which was neglected for a long time

KT
RRW

Parsha Shof'tim - To King or Not to King

Canadians undoubtedly will favour the Royalist Position whilst Americans will undoubtedly favour the Republican Position!

The Torah states WHEN you ask for a KING you shall surely place one -
Even [or especially] when asking to be like the surrounding nations.

Sh'muel [with Hashem's approbation] protests that his people requested a King just like "the Goyim"

If our Sidrah-Parsha is telling us that this appointment is optional and subjunctive to a request, this all makes perfect sense. Then, the objection was to the Request for appointing that King. But, once requested, that request Must be Honoured as per Torah Law in our Parshah.

However, Rambam Sefer Hamitzvot et. al. REQUIRE a King. And by implication require asking for one. Then Sh'muel's protests seem difficult to fathom.

I have some answers but I was wondering what you readers might say?

KT
RRW

Sunday, 16 August 2009

The Poseiq with the Caveat

A Major Poseiq made a sweeping caveat in his introduction

"My decisions are NOT meant to overturn existing customs"

Who said it?
A) Rema
B) Rosh
C) Bet Yosef
D) Tosafot
E) Rambam

Given this caveat which makes the most sense?

A) the poseiq was catering to concensus
B) given this caveat he was free to speak his mind freely w/o regard to hurting anyones feelings
C) This caveat was not meant as serious
D) none of the above

Shavua Tov
RRW

Two Rav Moshes - and Oral Traditions

It is interesting how "non-Ashkenazim" accept w/o much ado that R Moshe De Leone's publication can deviate from Talmudic norms - because after all the Zohar is predicated upon a Masorah!

Yet some of these same supporters of textless Masorah are clueless how R Moshe Isserles can publish halachos that apparently contradict with Talmud though based upon Masorah and even published Teshuvos - such as Maharil or T'rumas Hadeshen.

What Gives?

Whose ox has R Moshe Gored? :-)

KT
RRW

Intellectual Honesty and "Cherry Picking" Quotes

In Tur + SA YD, there is a debate about the "minhag" of excluding women from shechita.

Agur says that women are excluded as no one sees them slaughter.

Bet Yosef protests:
Lo Ra'inu eino raya. Lack of witnessing an event is no proof that it did not happen nor that it could not happen

Shach counters BY
By minhag lo ra'inu is a Raya. IOW granted in the realm of Halachah the BY is correct - but this is about Minhag. In this context construe Minhag as "Policy".
I have heard the BY quoted by some people as proof positive that women may not be excluded from doing "X" simply because women haven't done it. This is true and fair

Q: Is this Fair and "Balanced" to quote the BY and consciously Omit the Shach? Is this type of "Cherry Picking" Intellectualy honest?

KT
RRW

SA + RYDS - Chol Hamoed and Shaving

Two Halachot seem innocent enough - yet subjected to closer scrutiny may trigger some questions


1) SA 531:1 it is a mitzva to shave erev Yom Tov

Q: What kind of Mitzva is this?

What's its source?

(Be'er Hagolah says it is "pashut" I.E. Implicit in Moed Qatan 14.

Is SA exceeding his authority to state this as a "mitzva"? After all there is no explicit positive act of legislation!


How would this Mitzva be construed if R JB Soloveichik [RYDS] or Rabbi Herschel Schachter had declared this a "mitzva"?


2) 531:2 one may not shave on Chol Hamoed EVEN if one shaved before YT started

Source: Be'er Hagolah 531:2 Tur, Hagahot Ashrei besheim Or Zarua, and "remaining posqim

I am told that RYDS disputed this and suggested shaving if one shaves regularly and has complied with se'if 1 and shaved before Yom Tov


Q: Has RYDS exceeded his Halachic authority by revising Halachah codified by SA based upon a consensus of Posqim


OR


Is RYDS within his authority in that no dispositive statement in Talmud prohibits this case - and what is NOT prohibited explicitly by Talmud is...

Ergo permitted?


KT

RRW

Thursday, 13 August 2009

Divine Command Theory

Micha Berger - along with Rabbi Hecht - is one of my main "rebbes" or mentors on Jewish philosophy.

This is student command theory in that this posting is a "command" or "demand" performance in that I requested Micha to compose this article.

Here is a teaser:
"In his essay "Euthyphro", Plato has Socrates ask a young student named Euthyphro, "Is what is righteous righteous because the gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is righteous?"

The Jewish spin would be to ask: Is an act good because Hashem chose to make it a mitzvah, or did Hashem command us to do it because it is good? What is the Source of morality?

The problem is that if you say that an act is good solely because Hashem commanded it, then He had no moral reason to tell us to do one set of things and not another. Can mitzvos be the product of Divine whim, the decision between "Thou shalt murder" and "Thou shalt not" entirely without any reason on His part? On the other hand, if there is an overarching definition of good and evil that Hashem conformed to, then we placed something "over" Him, something that even He is subject to.."

Now get yourself a block of time
And sip some coffee, tea or wine and

See the remainder @ http://www.aishdas.org/asp/2009/08/divine-command-theory.shtml

KT
RRW

Wednesday, 12 August 2009

Humility in Criticizing from Rabbi Asher Lopatin

Preface:
For Modern Orthodox or Liberal Orthodox to have the proper "cache" or gravitas in critiquing to the right, they must step up their level of commitment, lest their criticisms serve as
"Self-seving"

See more on this at:

"Rabbi Asher Lopatin on Morethodoxy: Exploring the Breadth, Depth and Passion of Orthodox Judaism"

Link:

http://morethodoxy.org/2009/07/28/humility-in-criticizing-rabbi-asher-lopatin/

-------------------------

PS My 2 Cents:

AISI: CENTRIST orthodoxy addresses this issue. It is a modern approach intellectually with the same "diqduq" in Observance as Hareidim.

The problem with the LW of Orthodoxy is they are perceived - fairly or unfairly - as "O-Lite". Thus, Centrism is Modern O w/o the Lite

KT

RRW

Tuesday, 11 August 2009

Arrests in New Jersey

The following is an article I wrote, on the events that transpired a few weeks ago when various rabbis were arrested in New Jersey and Brooklyn. Your comments are most welcomed.
(The article appeared, originally, in the Jewish Tribune (Toronto) and can be seen on line at http://www.jewishtribune.ca/TribuneV2/index.php/200908111949/We-must-ask-ourselves-What-can-I-do-to-affect-change.html)
* * * * *

We must ask ourselves: What can I do to affect change?

I was – as were so many others around the world – truly stunned, embarrassed and troubled by the recent arrest of a group of Orthodox rabbis in Brooklyn and New Jersey. How could this have happened? How will antisemites use this information to cause further harm to the Jewish community? What will people say about Orthodoxy? These were questions that I heard asked and that I read in numerous articles. Comments further abounded: these rabbis profaned the Name of God; they caused a great chilul Hashem; they reflected so much of what is wrong within their specific communities. They did this and they did that – yet it still is we who will all suffer the consequences of their behaviour.
On the theological plane, we could ask: if they are the wrong-doers, why must we all suffer? If antisemitism is, lo aleinu, strengthened because of the actions of these few individuals, the entire Jewish community is the potential victim. We can thus wonder about the Divine justification for the many to suffer because of the actions of the few, of the very few. My issue, however, is not theological; it is much more practical. Whether we like it or not, we all still suffer the consequences. What then is the benefit of simply responding by solely distancing ourselves from the perpetrators of these acts? Yet, the responses I kept reading in regard to these events were developed with just this agenda. The overriding motivation seemed to be this desire to distance oneself from the accused parties – that’s them, that’s not me or not us. As if the antisemite will distinguish between you and other Jews, especially such visible Jews.
If we all suffer together, we are all in it together. This is not to say that we should not identify evil and the roots of this evil, yet maybe our response should also include a reflection of this reality of our interconnectedness.We may ask: to whom were these individuals – with their attempts to distance themselves from the perpetrators of these crimes – directing their comments? We may also wonder about a possible hidden agenda behind some of these variant statements. In the most basic sense, those attempting to distance themselves from the perpetrators are attempting to tell others not to include them in any negative responses towards the perpetrators. Does one really think, though, that proclamations that you are not part of this villainous group will cause another, who originally sees you in this light, to change his/her perspective? In the broadest context, do we actually think that by proclaiming that Jews who do criminal acts are not representative of the greater community, we can actually change the mind of the antisemite who already views the Jewish community with contempt and thinks that all Jews really are criminals? Even as we know that the truth is that there may be a wide divide between the general Jewish community and its few members who act with criminal intent, we cannot let ourselves be satisfied with stating the obvious, believing that it will solve all the potential problems. We will all still face potential consequences together, as a we. Thus, we must respond to the problem as a we.
This also applies within narrower contexts, when we attempt to distance ourselves from perpetrators such as these by declaring them members of a particular sub-group within our people and distancing ourselves from that sub-group. They are Orthodox, it’s a problem in Orthodoxy; of course, I am not Orthodox and, thus, not part of the problem. They are ultra-Orthodox or haredim, it’s a problem in ultra-Orthodoxy or the haredi culture; of course, any critiques are inapplicable to me since I’m not haredi. This is not to say that we should not identify negative behaviour emanating from certain groups within the Jewish world or that we should not be virulent in promoting the expression of values in which we believe in the Jewish world. But how often do we turn to such a solution, choose an explanation built upon distancing ourselves from the other, because it promotes our specific group? And how often do we not, thereby, recognize that parts of the problem may arise, to some extent, because of our own inherent friction? Declaring that a negative event may reflect, specifically, a haredi problem, for example, may have some legitimacy yet such an answer may also allow non-haredi individuals to ignore any challenges to themselves and their viewpoints as well, because they simply found the answer in blaming the other.
There is another potential consequence in this process of attempting to distance oneself. I read of one person who stated that people should not judge the entire Syrian Jewish community by the actions of these men. I never even thought of this possibility, that these actions were potentially reflective of a possible moral weakness within this particular community. These comments, presented as a defence for the community, actually made me start to contemplate what the possible problems are, within this community, which would make people think that the actions of these men were indicative of this community’s general mores. If there is a perceived need to defend a community from specific attacks, the problem is not simply the attacks themselves, but also, the very perception that such attacks could be justified.
There is a classic tale of Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan, the saintly Chofetz Chaim, in which an accusation of wrong was made against him by some evil individual. The story, though, continues that it was immediately rebuffed because of the very ridiculousness of such an accusation. That must be our communal goal. It should be that there is not even the need to distance ourselves from the perpetrators because it is obvious that these perpetrators were deceiving everyone by representing themselves as members of the Jewish community – for everyone knows that Jews, committed to their Jewishness, do not act in this manner.
My argument ultimately is not that there is no need to distance ourselves from perpetrators of such criminal acts nor to identify weaknesses within specific sub-groups within our people that may be, advertently or inadvertently, spreading a message that may give rise to such behaviour. While the antisemite will not hear such arguments, it is important to present such messages to ensure that naïve individuals within the greater population do not become fodder for these racist pronouncements.
Similarly, it is important to identify weaknesses within various sub-groups so that they can, and hopefully will, confront and rectify them. Unfortunately, the actual response will, rather, often be to simply grow defensive and ignore the challenges, as one often notes only the attack. In any event, what is the very purpose of this process of distinguishing? Does the average member of our society note the distinction between Orthodox and non-Orthodox Jews? Does the average secular Jew note the distinction between haredi Orthodoxy and non-haredi Orthodoxy? We all suffer the consequences of such events as those that transpired in New Jersey together. Our response must reflect this reality of interconnectedness.
In more specific terms, there are challenges we all face when attempting to maintain a strong and identifiable Jewish community within a broader, open society. This demands a balancing of forces of inclusion with forces of exclusion. Sometimes the desire for strength in Jewish identity can, though, yield a negation of the mores of the broader society. When the law of the land is broken, it can reflect such a weakness – the result of a view that the standards of the general society need not be respected because they are not Jewish. Our response, though, cannot simply be to attack those within the Jewish world who we perceive as advocating such a “solution” to the challenge of finding our balanced place in society. The broader need is to further articulate this challenge and advocate how we must all be careful to ensure that we properly balance the necessary respect for the greater society with the necessary respect for our Jewish uniqueness.
Of course, realistically, there are still “bad apples” within the Jewish people who, sadly, can wreak havoc on our community’s image and, regarding which, we can do little or nothing. The majority can suffer because of the acts of the minority, even the miniscule minority. Yet, when we attempt to find something that we can do, we empower ourselves. We must ask: how do these events identify weaknesses that I tolerate within myself and my community; and what can I do to affect change? No matter how difficult it may be for us to ask this question, it is one that we must face – and answer.

Rabbi Ben Hecht

Rabbi Angel's Blog on Geirut

For a Halachic review of Geirut - the ideal and the practical
See:

http://www.jewishideas.org/articles/more-issue-conversion-judaism

Question
I knew a ger who kept all mitzvot AFAIK

But on December 25 he would disappear and do XMAS, he simply could not give up that early experience.

Any Comments?

KT
RRW

Orthodox Women Clergy

"The best way to accomplish this is for our community to start many different training programs for Orthodox women who wish to work as clergy. " Rabbi Michael Broyde

More on this interesting perspective may be found at:

http://www.jewishpress.com/pageroute.do/40150

RRW

Monday, 10 August 2009

Using Spirituality to Explain the Horror of the Holocaust

It's really tough to fathom the depth and breadth of sueffering incurred during the Sho'ah



It's even tougher as a rabbi to deal with it; to confront survivors who lost so much. What can one say?



Lulei demistefina! While we cannot describe or ascribe the fundamentals of the dynamics - nevetheless Lessons CAN be learned and MUST be learned! It is our job as thinking analytical creatures to contemplate and reflect upon these grand events - whether they be the Triumph of the Exodus - which requires a night of reflection. Or the catastrophe of the Holocaust which make take us 2-3 generations to process.



One spirtual insight helps us put some distance from the suffering. This is reflected in most Spiritual Traditions, and in Judaism mostly via Qabbalah.



And that is - "We are NOT our bodies!" Thus take the Jewish martyr Rabbi Aqiva - his body was destroyed but not the soul, not the persona. R Aqiva himself, what makes him R. Aqiva is invulnerable to any harm from any human.



The body of R. Aqiva and his fellow martyrs are like the parchment, but that saming burning parchment releases its letters into the ether. A Mashal to body and spirit!



Another mashal is that our bodies are like a robe or an overcoat. What is destroyed during martyrdom is finite and mortal



Nevertheless, bodies have feelings and senses. So the analogy is by no means exact, perfect. The Jews who died suffered! It was not like they died peacefully under anasthesia.



Perhaps a better mashal: like bandages being ripped of one's skin in a most painful manner. The bandages are NOT the body, nevertheless their removal is painful



Similarly one's body is not one's essence, but as martyrs its removal was most painful.



Nevertheless nothing of "consequence" died - except perhaps the communities and institutions that furthered a vibrant Jewish life in pre-war Europe. They were victims of this Hurban - just as our Beis Hamiqdash was



May HKBH yemalei chesroneinu

Bmeheira beyameinu!



KT

RRW

Friday, 7 August 2009

Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur - Out of Order?

In Ner Israel many thoughtful students pondered the meanings and the messages of the High Holy Days - Yamim Nora'I'm

A very provocate question went as follows:

Given that RH is a day of judgment - Yom Haddin

And
Given that Yom Kippurim is a Day of Atonement and forgiveness.

The wouldn't it make MORE sense to Have Yom Kippur FIRST so that we would FIRST be forgiven all our trespasses and THEN go into the New Year with a clean slate?

Why have this "reverse" order.

Several responses were given.

A lengthy response will be given BEH during my Scholar-in-Residence Shabbat. For source material, I will focus primarily upon Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 128.

SS
RRW

Thursday, 6 August 2009

Aroch haShulchan and A Tale of Two Humros

In YD 89:11 AhS seems to accept the premise of the Rema - namely that we wait after Hard Cheese to eat meat, just like we wait after meat in order to eat dairy. Although he does acknowledge that
"Rabbim ein nizharin bezeh.."

However, in YD 89:17 he objects to a gzeira about kashering a keli back and forth from meat to dairy

A it's a humra yeseira
B ein lanu ligzor gzeiros midaateinu

Q: Mah nafshach! Siman 89 has many humros and gzeiros not found in the Talmud! Why pick on this one?

KT
RRW.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

Wednesday, 5 August 2009

Eqev: Who Inscribed the Second Luchos?

Originally published 8/5/09, 6:45 pm.
Given:
Hashem both carved and inscribed the First Luchos.
Moshe hewed the Second set of Luchos
Who inscribed this second set?

We have some ambiguities in the text.
We can resolve them by means of the 13th principle of Rabbi Yishma'el, "Vechein sh'nei ch'suvim  amach'chishim ze es zeh.."

First the conflicting bit:
1. Shnei Ch'suvim:
Shmos 34:1, HKBH writes the Second Luchos: "V'chasavti al halluchos"

2. Sh'mos 34 "K'sav lecha.." Moshe is writing on (luchos? Or something else?)

Although the two do not completely contradict each other, they do seem ambiguous.
This week's Parsha, Eqev, to the rescue!
The scale tipper: Hakkatuv hashlishi:

3. Dvarim Eqev Ch. 10:2-4 "v'echtov al halluchos" where it is clear that HKBH wrote on the 2nd Luchos.
I think this structure is clear. Therefore, in #2, Moshe probably wrote something else or wrote the dibros upon something else, like parchment.

KT,
RRW











Eqev, Mishnah, Sukkah - Perfect Misunderstanding

Originally published 8/5/09, 3:08 pm.
The Land Of Israel is unique:

D'varim 11:12:

A land that the L-rd Your G-d always Seeks
Always Hashem's Eyes are upon her.


Rashi s.v. Tamid to see what she news and to INNOVATE edicts, sometimes for the good and sometimes for the evil.

##############

The mishnah was developed and redacted in the Land of Israel.

Thus, it is logical and reasonable that the above supposition is a given premise - at least running in the background of the minds of the Tannaim.

##############

Mishna Sukkah 2:9

When it rains - they made a parable: like a servant who fills the goblet for his master and the master dumps it in his face.

Based upon Rashi, this is a case of a negative Gezeira that HKBH might, C"V, create when Israel misbehaves in the Land of Israel.

##############

Perfect Misunderstanding

That is to assume when it rains in the Golah - such as in North America, that Hashem is altering the weather pattern of the masses to smite the few Jews - say in North America. This may be beyond misunderstanding and approaching hubris that the weather in exile - Sukkos or not - is only Jewish-centric.

This is because the context of this Mishnah has been ignored! Reasonable premises about a Jewish Society are illogical when applied to Jews living in a Gentile Society!

----------------------

May we all Merit to sit in the Sukkah in our Holy Land, EY, bimheira beyameinu.


KT,
RRW

Tuesday, 28 July 2009

On Isms, TIDE and TuM, Pt. 1

[An extension of a discussion on Avodah]





Just a few blocks from each other a mini Kulturkampf exists between the Breuer community and the YU community.



The issue TIDE vs. TuM

Or Torah I'm Derech Eretz vs. Torah uMada.



The Hirschians assert that TIDE means absorbing Torah and wordliness BUT that Torah is the only valid prism by means which one sees the world

Thus Torah is supreme - Torah uber alles. Yet Torah can be applied to engineering or medicine the way one applies it to a "Blatt G'mara"



Furthermore Hirschians allege that TuM means seeing science w/o Torah as valid - and further as an equal to Torah may (or will) dillute it or corrupt it. And that this is unacceptable.



TuM devotees would demur that this is not quite the goal of Torah uMada. As Dr. Belkin might have said, One Studies pure Torah and then one studies pure "liberal arts" and goes home and makes his own synsthesis. Thus any potential "corruption" is not in the Torah classroom (the Blatt shiur) but in the individual.



But even this sells TuM Short. Ideally a purebred Torah devotee absorbs science not to modify, dillute., or corrupt Torah, rather to expand, enlighten, and to clarify Torah.



Example - Tanninim Gedolim means one thing to people unfamiliar with science. But a TuM student can easily see that science posits dinosaurs, and now the torah text can be better understood (not revised or compromised!) By adding this piece of information to one's tool-chest! Peshat can be clearer and enhanced by adding Mada to the mix!



However, the danger lurks, nevertheless, that Madda may lead one off the correct path. However, Madda should never be the sole prism by means with which one views Torah. Rather, Torah is learned on its own and Madda shouls merely enhance that View.



Part II

The Danger of the Isms



Kt

RRW



Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

Monday, 27 July 2009

Sinat Chinum - Purposeless Hatred

The term sinat chinum is usually translated as baseless hatred, yet what does that term even mean? Is hatred ever baseless? While we can argue that a reason for the hatred is problematic, foolish, even unjustifiable, can we truly apply the word "baseless"? There always is a reason, even if we think the reason is wrong. Furthermore, can one really state that the hatred that emerges in the famous story of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza is baseless? I think that, while I may strongly disagree with,how the person dealt with his negative emotions, there was reason for why they developed.

For all these reasons and more, I have chosen to translate sinat chinum as purposeless hatred, in other words hatred that is not acted upon correctly. We all develop negative emotions; the question is how we respond to these emotions. The response to hatred may not be to simply declare that it should not exist but to respond to the hatred correctly. To make this emotion, in the end, serve a postive purpose. Sinat Chinum is when we just allow it to exist and not strive to serve this purpose.

I invite you to read more about this in my two part essay Defining Sinat Chinum at
http://www.nishma.org/articles/insight/insight5757-22.htm
and
http://www.nishma.org/articles/insight/insight5757-23.htm

Rabbi Ben Hecht

Parsha: How did Hatzi Shevet Menashe Get There?

"Bnai Gad and Reuven approach Moshe about staying in East Jordan.



Question - how did the "half-tribe of Menashe get into the picture?



And why Menashe over another tribe?



I have a surprise answer"



OK clear your minds.



I taught a parsha class for many years @ Cong Mt Sinai in Wash Heights



I found that much of the tribal dynamics had to do with the Matriarchs - viz. Jacob's 4 wives.



I don't have the time or space now but use that as a prism for viewing inter-tribal dynamics...



Now apply that here:



Reuven - Leah

Gad - one of the 2 maidservants (Zilpah)



Q; Whose missing?



A: Rachel



Now proportion:

Leah has 6 sons of

But Levi gets no land leaving 5



So Reuven is about 20% of Leah



Gad is about 25% of the maidservants



Needed? 20-25% of Rachel



Half Menasseh - about 12.5 to 20% depending on how you compute. (Menasseh is MUCH larger than either Ephraim or Benjamin)



So Moses' agenda was to conform East-Jordan to a matriarchical balance. Half (or part of) Menasseh did the trick



Proof?

None

Hint?

Look at the configuration of the tribes in pasrshiyot Bamidbar and Beha'alotecha. They march by matriarch -

Except forGad who gets promoted to replace Levi with Reuven and Shim'on.



This model "suggests" the Torah had a matriarchical proportion re: tribe vs tribe



Since Half-menasseh jumps out of the clear blue sky, I simply plugged them in and voila! It conformed to a an existing model.





KT

RRW



Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

Ma'akeh, Safety at Work, Profit

Originally published 7/2/09, 12:02 am.
Recently, the following string of events occurred:

A friend of mine was injured at the (fictional) Jewish Institute of Hackensack building. Apparently, a repair to the brick stairs was not made properly and he got quite shaken up on a loose brick...

While investigating the Mitzva and Halachah of Ma'akeh, someone pointed out that there is no Torah requirement to make the work-place safe.

I'm not convinced.

The Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 184:5 states that it is prohibited to allow any hazard that may cause one to get injured.

Plus there is the requirement of a Ma'akeh which prohibits allowing a hazard lest someone fall.

Question: are those who look the other way or justify these blatant kinds of hazards a form of Rodef?

At any rate, while I support the economic freedoms we enjoy in North America, unbridled capitalism can engender an unsafe and even cutthroat society.

B"H most modern societies have curbed extreme capitalism, and AISI, it is antithetical to Torah ideals.

Think of the prohibitions of lo sachsom (the last few dappim in Bava Metiza) and the absolute socialism enforced by during the shemitta year.

Of course - it goes without saying -  the Torah opposes unbridled socialism, too.

Rather, the Torah economy is not subject to any "ism." It transcends them all. While elements of several "isms" co-exist,  anyone who is a TRUE Marxist or a TRUE capitalist cannot be true to the transcending Torah. By defiintion it is a compromise.

The same may be said for other isms.

But this post is about not letting the great Mammon undermine our loyalty to Hashem, the People of Israel, and the Torah way.





KT,

RRW