Tuesday 3 June 2014

Shavuot: Assavim vs. Ilanot

See Rema O"Ch 494:3 who brings down "Assavim"

See there Ba'er Hetev 7 who adds "l'haamid Ilanot" quoting Magen Avraham [MGA]

See M"B 10
First he quoties Rema re: Assavim
Then he quotes MGA re: Ilanot

Apparently the way the M"B frames it, the GRA opposes Ilanots [MGA] and not [so much] Assavim [Rema]

This may be verified by Maaseh Rav who mentions davka Ilanot.

QED
Kein Nir'eh Lee.

Kol Tuv,
RRW

No comments: