On Motz'ei Shabbos - we had a lively discussion re: learning
Halachah in general and learning Kitzur S"A in particular. I thought it
to be worth sharing
1. KSA covers many topics well. EG I feel KSA covers a good subset of Aveilus and Niddah
2. Unlike EG Hayyei Adam, it covers elements of Y"D, Even ho'Ezer and Choshen Mishpot
3.
Perhaps it is weakest re: Shabbos and Pesach. I suggested supplementing
KSA with EG Zichru Toras Moshe or Hayyei Adam for Shabbos, and with R
Shimon Eider's Sefer on Hil. Pesach
4.
I saw a letter by R Ganzfried suggesting he used a "Beis Din" of Hayyei
Adam, S"A haRav, and the Derech Chaim By R Yaakov miLisa.
5.
Kitzur S"A is a popular limmud amongst Hassidim, BUT they don't
slavishly follow it l'ma'aseh. Rather, they use it mostly as a Textbook
of Halachah.
No comments:
Post a Comment