Sunday 10 April 2011

Qitniyyot and TB Megillah 5b

Originally published 4/10/11, 12:12 pm.
See M'gillah 5b regarding planting on Purim.

«But now that we have established that work is permitted on Purim, [then] why did RAV curse the man whom he saw sowing flax?

Because it was a case of "things that are essentially permitted yet some treat them as forbidden" .... RAV therefore cursed the man for violating the custom» [tr schottenstein]

How is the custom of qitniyyot any different?

Don't they also constitute a case of an essentially permitted food that some treat as forbidden?

Shalom,
RRW

1 comment:

Mighty Garnel Ironheart said...

The issue isn't the basic idea of kitniyos. It's that every year more food gets added to the list!