Thursday, 13 September 2012

S"A O"Ch 10:7, Hetzyo Satum..

Mar'eh M'komomot
S"A O"Ch 10:7
BH"T 9, 10
M"B 26,27
Sha'ar Hatziyyun 34,35
Citing L'vush MGA, Eliyah Rabbah etc.

In a recent M"B Yomit I came across the case of a a beged "Hetzyo satum and Hetzyo patu'ach"

In this case one is hayyav b'tzitzit missafeik, no b'rachah is made, and one may not wear them outside on Shabbat. The Acharonim dispute if this prohibition applies to Carmelit or not.

Given, since these Tzitzit are a Hiyyuv [albeit misafeik]

Q: Now why are the Tzitziyot deemed a Massuy, a burden? Since one is Hayyav to have them,  shouldn't that obviate them being a massuy?

Shanah Tovah,
Best Wishes for 5773!

1 comment:

Rabbi Rich Wolpoe said...

See SA O"Ch 13:1+2 and M"B there

EG nightime one may wear tztzis on Shabbos EVEN when pattur due to noy

Even if midrabbanan

Now see M"B 4 v'ieno domeh to hetzyo satum.
M"B says since hiyyuvam mitzad safeik. I'm not clear what's the difference.

Also see Shaarei T'shuva 13:2

Shanah Tovah,
Best Wishes for 5773!