Mishnah text:
«ROSH HASHANAH: CHAPTER 4: MISHNAH 5
Order of the blessings: one recites the Patriarchs, Powers, and the Holiness of the Name, and includes Malkhuyot, but he does not blow; the Sanctity of the Day, and he blows; Zikhronot, and he blows; Shofarot, and he blows; and he recites Service, and Thanksgiving, and the Priests' Blessing; so Rabbi Yohanan ben Nuri.
Rabbi Akiva said to him, If he does not blow for Malkhuyot, why does he mention? Rather he recites Patriarchs, Powers, and the Holiness of the Name, and includes Malkhuyot in the Sanctity of the Day, and he blows»
R Yochahan Ben Nuri:
...and the Holiness of the Name, and includes Malkhuyot, but he does not blow;...
Rabbi Aqiva:
and the Holiness of the Name, and includes Malkhuyot in the Sanctity of the Day, and he blows
Kehatti (and fwiw Bartenura)
«The halakhah follows Rabbi Akiva»
Given the above
Do we all agree halachically speaking - that since we follow R Aqiva and reject RY Ben Nuri -
therefore Malchuyot is to be found exclusively in Qedushat Hayyom and also NOT to be found in Qedushat Hashem?
Please let me know if this is a correct assumption.
For a complete text including Kehatti see:
http://www.moreshet.net/oldsite/mishna/10-9-00/sunday.htm
Shana Tova
RRW
No comments:
Post a Comment